The 7 Best Composts For Gardens: A Gardener’s Guide

Geobin Composting System

Geobin Composting System is the perfect alternative to open, messy compost piles. It is what you need when you a compost that easy to set up and move. This bin is an excellent alternative to a pile on the ground, and it keeps your compost cooking and contained.  

Product Highlights

The Geobin compost bin can hold up to a notably 14 bushels of material. The bin is made from lightweight but sturdy plastic with many ventilation holes to allow an enormous amount of air into the pile from all sides. This bin has the best aeration and is perfect for those who prefer the ease of an open compost pile. This sturdy bin holds up to 216 gallons of compost when it is fully assembled, and closes along the sides with heavy plastic closure keys. 

The Good

Filling the Geobin creates a compost pile of the ideal size of about three cubic feet, which enables the pile to heat up properly for maximum effectiveness. The result is a more efficient compost pile that produces finished compost in less time. The plastic mesh material provides more ventilation and moisture control to your compost pile and resists all types of weather conditions. If properly maintained, odor and insects shouldn’t be a problem. 

The Bad

Since the bin is open at the top, animals and other pests could get into the container. Some users have said that the bin needed additional stakes to keep it from falling over. They added that the stakes supplied with the bin are a bit too short of securing the bin to the ground properly. 

FLORA GUARD 3-Pack 72 Gallons Garden Waste Bags 

If you want a heavy-duty compost bags with handles, the FLORA GUARD 3-Pack 72 Gallons Garden Waste Bags is what you need. It holds up to 72 gallons of garden waste for maximum yard clean up with minimal effort. 

Product Highlights

Its durability is proven, and it is also versatile enough to be used for collecting weeds, grass clippings, other types of yard waste. The set of three garden bags has a maximum capacity of 72 gallons for each bag. Its height measures 30” and diameter 26”. It includes a flexible hoop to increase stability and keep the bag open, which help to easy to fill and easy to empty. This makes it one of the best composts for gardens. 

The Good

The garden waste bag is made from UV-treated polypropylene tarpaulin. This foldable yet firm bag saves a lot of storage space. The bag’s fabric is tear-resistant and water-repellent.  

The bags are very convenient for traveling and saving space, too. They shrink down to practically nothing in size. 

The Bad

The bag doesn’t stand on its own when empty. You should also avoid to drag it on the ground as it is susceptible to get holes. 

Redmon Since 1883 8000 Compost Bin

For the simplest solution to your composting needs, you can use the Redmon Since 1883 8000 Compost Bin. It has a large capacity compost bin that comes with four doors that are easy to access. It is a traditional unit that can easily handle vast quantities of leaves, kitchen waste, trimmings, and other compostable materials. 

Product Highlights

The high-quality compost bin is resistant to high-impact UV rays and can last for more extended periods. The bin has a capacity of 65 gallons, which is perfect for holding a large amount of food and other waste. It comes with four doors that are easy to access that helps to the quick adding and removing of the compost material. It also features ventilation holes on all sides for proper airflow and fast composting. It also has a removable lid for adding more material quickly. 

The Good

The compost bin also BPA and phthalate-free and comes with ventilation holes that ensure proper aeration inside. It comes without a bottom, making it sit directly on the soil. This bin makes it a perfect option for outdoor composting use. You can add fresh food to this compost bin regularly so that the farm worms inside can break down the material efficiently and quickly. This compost bin will also ensure that the worms stay inside the compost bin and do not seep down into the soil for more food. It is also easy to assemble. 

The Bad

Since it comes without a bottom, it is not movable with it is filled. Very few users took notice of its flimsy construction. Some also found it hard to assemble when they first use it.   

EJWOX Garden Compost Bin – Dual Rotating Outdoor Composting Tumblers

EJWOX Garden Compost Bin – is a dual-chamber composter that allows for continuous composting. It perfectly suits for your garden and for people not wanting to mix the organic waste in their traditional compost bin.  

Product Highlights

This compost bin features a dual rotating outdoor garden compost. The aerated internal bar mixes the compost and allows the needed airflow. The bin turns on the axis on a smooth and balanced rotation. The black, double-wall panels absorb and retain heat. You get to fill one chamber as the other one is composting. The easy-slide doors will help keep track of each batch. The length of one door is 10.23,” and the width is 6.1”. 

The Good

It features enough height to put a cart under the composter. The powder-coated steel frame provides a sturdy base for the large bin while the galvanized steel feet prevent rusting and deterioration. The compost bin is suitable for fast batch composting. EJWOX Garden Compost Bin – Dual Rotating Outdoor Composting Tumblers is a plastic made compost equipment which can hold a maximum waste of as high as 43 gallons. It is easy to assemble and with the simple instructions provided. 

The Bad

Some users found it harder to rotate when the compost bin is full, which could be improved if it has a handle for rotation. They also noted that the plastic materials used in the bin need improvement in terms of quality. 

FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling Composter 

The FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling Composter allows you to avoid digging and mixing your compost pile using your hand. It’s useful tumbling design makes mixing easy and efficient. 

Product Highlights

This compost bin is a significant design tumbling composter with a capacity of 37 gallons. It is an eight-sided dual tumbler with a unique tumbling design that assists in making easier mixing. The compost bin has two separate sides, with doors on each for the natural separation of the compost material. The compost tumbler smoothly rotates and mixes the elements. The compost can quickly be done in a mere 2-3 days when the right conditions are met. The composter is also weatherproof, so heavy rains cannot your compost. The composter’s black plastics are good at trapping and retaining heat. 

The Good

This durable tumbler is made with 100 percent recycled polypropylene. It is BPA-free, and the UN inhibited. This bin features excellent aeration with holes on both sides while the large openings and removable door enable easy adding of scraps and removing of finished compost. The deep fins on the body provide excellent ergonomic handholds. Continuous swapping of the sides after finishing will create an uninterrupted flow of good compost.  

The Bad

The composter takes quite hard while to assemble, but once assembled, it will stand the tests of time. This compost bin is not suitable for large batch compost. Some users noted that the composter doesn’t have an adequate drainage system, so leaks are expected. 

SQUEEZE master Compost Bin 43 Gallon Outdoor Tumbler

SQUEEZE master Compost Bin 43 Gallon Outdoor bin’s resilient thickness and functional design help generate and insulate heat that produces nutrient-rich soil by breaking down micro-organisms. It is an affordable compost bin without compromising its durability. 

Product Highlights

The bin has a large capacity of 12.6 cubic feet that generates organic compost humus from food and garden waste in two months. The top doors keep animals out of this composing bin while the openings promote excellent circulation inside. Air can freely enter the bin that speeds up the composting process by as much as six weeks. This makes it one of the best composts for gardens. 

The Good

The compost bin’s sturdiness is further increased if you place the bin on level ground. This bin is great to use for those who wish to recycle their kitchen waste effectively. No professional assembly is needed to assemble this bin. The bin locks tightly with two knobs placed on both sides. This particular locking system will protect the compost inside, so you are assured that it will contain all your organic waste and other scraps safely. 

The Bad

Few customers have complained about the manual effort needed for this compost bin to function well. You need to make sure to turn the compost regularly, which is difficult work. Some customers have also complained about the amount of time they spent unloading this product. A few customers made reviews on issues regarding a mildly unpleasant odor during the heat of the summer months, which needs a small amount of garden soil to minimize the smell. 

Goplus Compost Tumbler Outdoor Garden Waste Bin

Goplus Compost Tumbler Outdoor Garden Waste Bin has a rotatable design. It is a heavy-duty constructed compost bin, which is one of the best in making garden composts. The combination of high-quality material and steel construction ensures that this compost bin is stable and durable. 

Product Highlights

This compost bin is rotatable to balance the ingredients and accelerate the speed of decomposing. It has some holes on the tumbler for better appearance and for some oxygen to get inside the compost. It is divided into two chambers: filled one side, while the other side cures, making it easy to efficiently convert your kitchen and yard waste into fertile soil enhancing compost. It has two compartments to keep fresh organic waste from older waste; separation makes better compost.   It is cleverly designed to turn on the axis for smooth and balanced rotation. 

The Good

This 43-gallon capacity bin is easy to use. It allows you to avoid digging and mixing your compost pile by hand. The tumbling design makes mixing easy and efficient. Just close the door and turn it 5-6 times every 2-3 days. In hot sunny conditions and with a proper balance of ingredients, the compost can finish in as little as two weeks. The compost material is enclosed and helps keep pests out.   

The Bad

The only downside that some users complain about this type of compost is that it is hard to assemble.